Hybrid cloud costs: comparing cloud and data centre fairly
How to put on-premise, VMware and public cloud side by side, on real numbers.
“Is the cloud cheaper than our data centre?” It’s one of the most common questions in any infrastructure review, and one of the most often answered wrongly. Not because the maths is hard, but because the two sides are rarely measured the same way.
The problem: two different kinds of bill
Public cloud sends you a detailed bill every month. Every resource, every hour, every gigabyte.
A data centre doesn’t. Its costs are spread across hardware purchases, licences, support contracts, power, space, network and people, often in different budgets and on different timelines. So the cloud looks expensive because every cost is visible, and on-premise looks cheap because many costs are hidden.
Step 1: Build a full cost of on-premise
To compare fairly, bring every on-premise cost into one monthly figure:
- Hardware: servers, storage and network, spread over their real lifetime
- Software: virtualisation (such as VMware), operating systems, databases, backup
- Facilities: space, power and cooling, or your colocation fees
- Support: hardware and software maintenance contracts
- People: the share of team time spent running the platform
Step 2: Allocate both sides the same way
Use the same owners for both worlds: the same teams, products and business units. A product that runs half in the cloud and half on-premise should show one total cost, not two reports in two formats.
Step 3: Compare workloads, not platforms
“Cloud versus data centre” is too broad to answer. “This workload, on this platform, at this cost” is not. Some workloads are steady and predictable and fit well on owned infrastructure. Others are spiky, short-lived or need managed services that are hard to build yourself.
Looking workload by workload usually leads to a mixed answer, and that’s fine. Hybrid isn’t a compromise when it’s a choice made on real numbers.
Step 4: Keep it current
Licensing models change, hardware ages and cloud prices move. A comparison made once and filed away goes stale within a year. Treat it as part of your regular FinOps reporting instead.
The takeaway
A fair comparison doesn’t need complex tools. It needs one consistent view of cost across every environment, which is exactly what FinOps is designed to give you.